Home > Positioning > Close affinity > The three core values

The three core values

SPLectrum’s metaphysics starts from three values disclosed from the subject’s lived situation: belonging (what is mine living also in others), privacy (what I experience is internal to me), creativity (the tension between what is shared and what is privately mine). They are not a foundation but a stance — stand in them and a world comes into view.

The tradition carries the three in different combinations. Four thinkers hold something like all three together, each from a different starting point; most develop one value in depth. The landscape below walks both: the four analogues, then each value across the traditions that carry it.


The analogues — four thinkers who hold all three

Taylor — three axes of modern identity

Charles Taylor’s Sources of the Self (1989) traces three axes of modern identity: inwardness (the self has depth, an interior to be explored and expressed), the dialogical self (identity formed through shared language and recognition), and authenticity (the demand to be true to one’s own originality). The mapping is close: inwardness rhymes with privacy, the dialogical self with belonging, authenticity with creativity.

Taylor’s project is genealogical — a history of how the modern West came to live selfhood this way, the three axes a historical achievement traced through its sources, and the scope the human language animal by design.

Whitehead — Creativity, Many, One

Alfred North Whitehead’s Process and Reality (1929) places creativity as the “ultimate” — the category that generates all others. The many become one and are increased by one. Each actual occasion prehends (takes in) the many that precede it and becomes a new one — a creative synthesis that adds to reality. Creativity, the many (belonging to a world of actual occasions), and the privacy of each occasion’s subjective aim form a structural triad.

Whitehead’s triad is cosmological: it holds for every actual entity, from an electron to God.

Nishida — self-awareness, mutual determination, action-intuition

Nishida Kitarō’s philosophy holds self-awareness (the inward fold — what I know of myself), mutual determination (how I am shaped by and shape my world), and action-intuition (creative engagement where knowing and acting are one) as co-original — three faces of one act, not three separate capacities. The mapping is close: self-awareness to privacy, mutual determination to belonging, action-intuition to creativity.

In Nishida the three find their unity in absolute nothingness — the place (basho) in which all tensions are held, a groundless ground.

Bakhtin — dialogism as belonging, privacy, and creativity in one concept

Mikhail Bakhtin’s dialogism holds all three values together through a single concept. Belonging: meaning is produced between speakers, not within them — every word is “half someone else’s,” and the utterance is always addressed, always responsive. Privacy: outsideness (vnenakhodimost’) — you see me as I cannot see myself, and this surplus of seeing is constitutive of understanding, not a limitation. The other’s perspective on my life is something I structurally cannot have from the inside. Creativity: polyphony — genuinely distinct voices held together without merging into one, producing new meaning through their interaction.

Bakhtin holds the three as features of how language works — of the utterance, the encounter between speakers, the novel as literary form: dialogism as a description of language in action.


Belonging — what is mine living also in others

Martin Buber — “All real living is meeting.” Relation is primary: the I of I-Thou is constituted by the encounter, not prior to it. Belonging, here, is encounter — not membership, not identity, but the meeting in which the self comes into being through the other. The framework centres on the pair: what happens between I and Thou.

Emmanuel Levinas — the face of the Other precedes all belonging. The ethical demand is infinite and asymmetrical — the Other’s claim on me is not reciprocal. Levinas places the Other at the centre, and the relation is asymmetrical by design. He also develops interiority — the subject as separated, enjoying its own inner life — which places him across belonging and privacy at once.

Martin Heidegger — Being-in-the-world is always already Being-with (Mitsein). The self is not first isolated and then socialised; it is from the start situated in a shared world of meaning. The priority of the shared is structural. His account of the shared world is oriented toward everydayness and the they (das Man) — the shared world as the condition from which authentic selfhood must be won.

Alasdair MacIntyre and Michael Sandel — the communitarian critique of the unencumbered self. The self is constituted by its community’s traditions, its shared moral frameworks, its practices. You cannot step behind your attachments and choose from nowhere. MacIntyre develops the point into tradition-constituted rationality; Sandel into the encumbered self against Rawls’s liberal abstraction. For both, belonging is constitutive of the self.


Privacy — what I experience is internal to me

Thomas Nagel — “What is it like to be a bat?” The subjective character of experience is irreducible: no amount of objective description captures what it is like to be a particular subject. Privacy, for Nagel, is the structural feature that blocks complete objectivity — the subjective point of view that the view from nowhere cannot absorb.

Emmanuel Levinas — interiority is positive, not a gap. The subject enjoys (jouissance) its own inner life before any encounter with the Other. Separation is a condition for ethics, not its obstacle — only a genuinely interior being can be addressed. Levinas places interiority and belonging in a sequence: separation first, encounter second.

Hannah Arendt — the private realm is the realm of necessity, the body, the household — the precondition for the public realm of action and speech, but subordinate to it. The private shelters the person who will appear in public, and the weight of Arendt’s framework falls on the public — plurality, action, the space of appearance.

Maurice Merleau-Ponty — the lived body is the site of privacy. Perception is always mine — embodied, perspectival, irreducibly first-personal. But the body is also intercorporeal: it reaches toward others, it inhabits a shared world. Merleau-Ponty holds the private and the shared together through the body without splitting them into separate domains.


Creativity — the tension between shared and private

Alfred North Whitehead — creativity as the ultimate category. Every actual occasion is a creative synthesis of its world. Whitehead makes creativity cosmological — it is what reality does at every level, not a human capacity but a feature of the cosmos.

Henri Bergson — the élan vital, creative evolution. Life is a creative impulse that diverges and differentiates as it advances. Creativity is not the application of intelligence to inert matter but the fundamental movement of life itself. Creation is irreducible and open-ended, and it belongs to life itself — the framework is vitalist.

Cornelius Castoriadis — the radical imaginary. Society creates its own forms — its meanings, norms, categories — through a collective creative capacity that cannot be derived from prior conditions. Autonomy is the project of making this self-creation conscious. Creativity, here, is social and ontological, not merely individual or artistic — the radical imagination of the psyche and the social imaginary of the collective held as two poles of one capacity.

Hannah Arendt — natality. Every birth introduces a new beginning into the world — the capacity to initiate, to start something that was not before. Action is the human activity that corresponds to natality: unpredictable, irreversible, disclosed in a web of relationships. Arendt locates creativity in the public realm — it is what happens between people in speech and action. Freedom, for her, is public.

William James — the unfinished universe. Reality is in the making, not ready-made. The world is genuinely open; novelty is real, not apparent. James holds this as a metaphysical conviction (radical empiricism, pluralism) and as a temperamental commitment (the tough-minded against the tender-minded).

Gilles Deleuze — difference is primary, not derivative. Repetition produces difference; identity is a product, not a ground. The virtual is the field of creative potential from which actual forms are differentiated. Deleuze makes creativity ontological and anti-foundational.


How the triad surfaces

The three values arrive separately across the tradition. Belonging is carried by the dialogical and communitarian thinkers (Buber, Levinas, Heidegger, MacIntyre, Sandel); privacy by the phenomenologists and philosophers of subjectivity (Nagel, Merleau-Ponty, Levinas’s interiority); creativity by the process philosophers and the theorists of social imagination (Whitehead, Bergson, Castoriadis, Arendt, James, Deleuze). Each strand carries its value with depth and precision.

Four thinkers hold something like all three at once, each through a different material: Taylor through a genealogy of the modern self, Whitehead through a cosmology, Nishida through the self-aware act, Bakhtin through the working of language. That the triad surfaces whole in materials this far apart — history, cosmos, act, utterance — is the resonance: the three tend to arrive together wherever thought takes up the subject among others.

Held together as a stance — belonging gives shared language, privacy gives something to express, creativity is the act of expression — the three bring a world into view: thick (privacy), porous (belonging), unfinished (creativity).


See also: Aesthetics · Pluralism